Simply the best

Remember that feeling of being spoiled by grandma?
Well, this is it - because you deserve it.

Whether you're waking up with your coffee, sitting with family after dinner, giving a gift, or having dessert at a wedding - Sandy's cookies compliment all occasions any time of day.

assorted cookies

Cookies made with love

Many varieties of traditional Italian cookies from family recipes passed down through the generations. Perfect for any occassion!

Muffins, biscotti, and more!

Scrumptious muffins, rich brownies, biscotti that goes perfect with coffee, and other delicious treats made by Sandy herself.

Homemade in Newburgh, NY

We are a local enterprise based in Newburgh, NY. We don't ship, but we do deliver locally for a small fee and always welcome pickup orders of any size!


All cookies are $15 per pound. One pound is about 23 cookies.

cashew white chocolate cookie

Cashew White Chocolate Cookie

cherry topped cookie

Cherry Topped Cookie

chocolate chip cookie

Chocolate Chip Cookie

chocolate covered cherry

Chocolate Covered Cherry Cookie

chocolate iced cookie

Chocolate Iced Cookie

chocolate peanut butter chip

Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip Cookie

Cinnamon Crescents

Cinnamon Crescents



lemon cookie

Italian Lemon Cookie

knot cookie

Italian Knot Cookie



mexican wedding

Mexican Wedding Cookie

black and white

Mini Black & White Cookie

oatmeal raisin cookie

Oatmeal Raisin Cookie

peanut butter cookie

Peanut Butter Cookie

kiss cookie

Peanut Butter Kiss Cookie

peanut butter middle cookie

Peanut Butter Middle Cookie

pink iced cookie

Pink Iced Cookie

raspberry sandwhich cookie

Raspberry Sandwhich Cookie

sprinkle cookie

Sprinkle Cookie

three layer cookie

Three Layer Cookie


Each biscotti is over-sized and $2 apiece.

almond biscotti

Almond Chocolate Chip

apricot almond biscotti

Apricot Almond

cherry chocolate chip biscotti

Cherry Chocolate Chip

cinnamon walnut biscotti

Cinnamon Walnut

cranberry pistachio biscotti

Cranberry Pistachio


Large brownies are $2 apiece. Smaller brownies are included in the assorted cookies!

chocolate chip brownie

Chocolate Chip

peanut butter swirl brownie

Peanut Butter Swirl

rolo brownie


walnut brownie



These large, artisan muffins sell for $2 apiece.

banana chocolate chip muffin

Banana Chocolate Chip

banana walnut muffin

Banana Walnut

blackberry muffin


blueberry muffin


cherry muffin


cinnamon pecan muffin

Cinammon Pecan

Cinammon Walnut

peach muffin



Place an order or say hello!